Monday, February 12, 2018

The Most Adequate Probes a Modest Amount of Money Can Buy

I needed some test probes for my electronics lab: things like banana plugs with alligator clips for the power supply, and minigrabbers for the multimeters. I ordered a bunch from ebay, $1-$1.50 each:
Pair Test Hook Clip to Straight Banana Plug Connector Lead Cable 1M New2 Pcs Red Black Banana Plugs to Alligator Clips Probe Test Cable 1M TS
When I finally got around to using them, I was testing a 12V, 2A light circuit from my power supply. For some reason the circuit was seeing only 10V! I guess because ... those lousy test leads were 1Ω! Ridiculous. Probably 60-gauge wire.

So, not wanting to repeat that debacle, I picked up a Pomona set for $16:
Pomona 3782-24-02 MINIGRABBER/Banana PLUG (SET) (Pack of 2)
Ten times the price, but at least they work! But I'd like to have a few of these things around; you never know when you need them. Can I find something cheaper but adequate? Amazon suggested Elenco TL-5 and TL-12 leads, and they showed up today.


I put them all to the test by running 3A through each, and measuring the voltage drop. I also compared against my homemade test leads: alligator clips crimped to speaker wire. Here are the results:

leadlengthmV/3AΩ through both leadsΩ/ft
Elenco TL-5 banana alligator3'4000.1 Ω0.033 Ω/ft
Elenco TL-12 banana minigrabber3'3000.133 Ω0.044 Ω/ft
Pomona Minigrabber2'1800.06 Ω0.030 Ω/ft
Howell lampcord alligator1.5'2400.08 Ω0.058 Ω/ft

So the Pomonas win by a little, but the Elencos are less than half the price, and pretty adequate. I wish they offered a shorter length.

No comments:

Post a Comment